We’ve heard this story countless times from our members. They follow a wellness influencer religiously. Every morning smoothie, every supplement recommendation, every “life-changing” morning routine. Then the influencer promotes something called “alkaline coffee” that supposedly balances your body’s pH and cures everything from bloating to brain fog. The problem? Our bodies already regulate pH incredibly well, and coffee’s acidity doesn’t actually matter once it’s metabolized.
It’s a pattern we see over and over. And honestly, it’s becoming harder to ignore.
The Influencer Effect Is Real (And That’s the Problem)
Here’s the thing about wellness influencers: they’re really good at what they do. The aesthetic flat lays, the aspirational lifestyles, the before-and-after photos. They create content that makes people want to believe. And there’s nothing wrong with inspiration, but somewhere along the way, inspiration became medical advice.
The numbers are staggering. A recent survey found that nearly 60% of young adults have tried a health trend they discovered through social media. Not from their doctor. Not from peer-reviewed research. From someone with good lighting and a ring light.
Not all influencers are acting in bad faith. Many genuinely believe in what they’re sharing. But belief and evidence are two very different things, and the gap between them can get expensive, or worse, dangerous.
When “Natural” Becomes a Red Flag
Let me explain something that many people take too long to understand: natural doesn’t automatically mean safe. Arsenic is natural. Poison ivy is natural. Just because something comes from the earth doesn’t mean you should ingest it or rub it all over your face.
Yet wellness influencers love the word “natural” almost as much as they love ring lights. They’ll promote “natural” supplements without mentioning potential drug interactions. They’ll suggest “natural” cleanses without acknowledging that your liver and kidneys already do this job for free. They’ll sell you on “natural” remedies that have zero scientific backing but great packaging.
The detox tea industry is a perfect example. Influencers promote these products as gentle, natural ways to “cleanse” your system. What they don’t mention? Many contain senna, a powerful laxative that can cause dependency and electrolyte imbalances when used regularly. But the packaging is pretty, and the influencer swears it changed her life, so thousands of followers click “buy now.”
The Credentials Gap Nobody Talks About
Here’s where things get tricky. Most wellness influencers aren’t doctors, nutritionists, or licensed healthcare providers. They’re people who got in good shape, developed a following, and suddenly found themselves giving health advice to thousands (or millions) of people.
Some have taken weekend certification courses. Others have read a lot of books. A few are legitimately educated in health sciences. But you can’t always tell which is which, and that’s by design. The wellness industry thrives on blurring these lines.
Influencers with “health coach” certifications (which can be obtained in weeks) often position themselves as authorities on complex topics like autoimmune conditions, hormone health, and mental illness. They’re not technically claiming to be doctors, but the framing, the confidence, the clinical-sounding language? It all creates an illusion of expertise.
"Belief and evidence are two very different things, and the gap between them can get expensive, or worse, dangerous."
The Comment Section Isn’t a Clinical Trial
Real talk: anecdotal evidence feels compelling. When you see dozens of comments saying “This changed my life!” it’s hard not to get swept up. But individual testimonials, no matter how heartfelt, don’t replace controlled research.
That supplement that “worked” for someone might have coincided with other lifestyle changes they made. That skin cream might have benefited from better lighting in the after photo. That dramatic weight loss might not be sustainable, healthy, or even real.
Wellness influencers know that stories sell better than statistics. They share transformation photos and emotional testimonials because that’s what converts followers into customers. Meanwhile, the actual research on their promoted products often tells a different story, or no story at all because proper studies haven’t been done.
The Financial Incentives We Ignore
Let’s address the elephant in the room: wellness influencing is a business. Those “honest reviews” and “favorite products” often come with affiliate links, sponsorship deals, or the influencer’s own product line. This doesn’t automatically make recommendations invalid, but it’s context everyone needs to consider.
When an influencer makes a commission every time someone clicks their supplement link, their motivation isn’t purely wellbeing. When they’ve created their own line of overpriced powders, they’re not going to suggest that basic nutrition might work just as well.
The most successful wellness influencers have monetized their platforms brilliantly. But it’s important to recognize that financial incentives can (and do) shape the content people consume.
So What Do We Do With All This?
We’re not suggesting anyone unfollow every wellness account or dismiss all alternative health approaches. But maybe we can all get a little more skeptical, a little more curious, a little more willing to ask questions.
Before trying that trending supplement, search for actual research. Before starting that restrictive diet, talk to your doctor. Before investing in that expensive program, ask what credentials the person has. And maybe, just maybe, remember that if something sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
The wellness industry isn’t going anywhere. Influencers will keep influencing, products will keep launching, and trends will keep trending. But we can all change how we engage with it.
Your health is too important to outsource to someone whose main qualification is knowing how to use Instagram filters. You deserve better than that. Everyone does.
Getting Real Support with TouchCare
Not sure what wellness services are covered through your work benefits? We can help you figure that out. Looking for a nutritionist, mental health provider, or specialist but dreading the search process? We’ll find qualified options for you. Need someone to actually schedule those appointments you keep putting off? That’s what TouchCare is here for!
Inhale. We've got this. Exhale.
Understanding healthcare; with us, it’s personal.